Seneca on worry

It is two in the morning and the meeting is not until Thursday. You have already lived through it several times: the awkward silence, the question you can't answer, the look on your manager's face. By the time Thursday comes, you will have been through it more often in your head than you ever will in the room.

Worry has a way of pulling the future into the present and making us live it in advance. This is not a modern problem. Nearly two thousand years ago, the Roman writer Lucius Annaeus Seneca wrote to a younger friend, Lucilius, about exactly this habit. His letters are still among the most practical things ever written about it.

Who Seneca was

Seneca lived in the first century, in Rome. He was a Stoic philosopher, a playwright, and for years an adviser to the emperor Nero, which gave him plenty of firsthand experience of fear, and his letters are honest about it. Late in life he wrote a series of letters to Lucilius, then a Roman official in Sicily, on how to live well. They read less like treatises and more like advice from an older friend who has been through it.

Stoicism is often presented online as a philosophy of toughness: endure everything, feel nothing. That is not how we use it. We take it as a starting position, a set of tools for separating what is in your control from what is not, and for understanding a feeling before acting on it.

"We suffer more often in imagination than in reality"

In his thirteenth letter, Seneca tells Lucilius that more things threaten to frighten us than actually crush us, and that "we suffer more often in imagination than in reality" (Seneca, c. 65/1917, Letter 13). He goes on to advise his friend not to be unhappy before the crisis arrives, since the dangers that make us turn pale may never come at all.

He then makes a careful distinction. Some things, he says, trouble us more than they should. Some trouble us before they should. And some trouble us when they should not trouble us at all. We tend to exaggerate our troubles, imagine them, or anticipate them.

These three categories are useful because they are specific. Worry tends to arrive as one large, shapeless feeling. Seneca's distinction breaks it into questions you can answer. Is this as big as it feels? Is it happening now, or later? Is it mine to worry about at all?

What research has found

Seneca's claim that most of what we fear never happens can be tested, and recently it was. In a study published in 2020, people being treated for generalised anxiety, a condition marked by persistent worry, wrote down their worries over ten days, along with what they feared would happen. Afterwards, they recorded what actually happened. Around 91 per cent of their worry predictions did not come true, and some of those that did turned out better than expected (LaFreniere & Newman, 2020).

That does not mean worry is always wrong. Some fears are accurate, and some worry leads to useful planning. Psychologists distinguish between repetitive thinking that leads to a plan or a solution and repetitive thinking that circles without arriving anywhere (Watkins, 2008). Seneca was making a similar point. He did not tell Lucilius to stop thinking about the future. He told him to examine his fears before letting them run his present.

Letter 1: time spent in advance

Seneca's first letter to Lucilius is about time. He writes that time is the one thing truly ours, and that we let it slip away through carelessness. He puts it sharply: "While we are postponing, life speeds by" (Seneca, c. 65/1917, Letter 1).

Worry is one of the ways time slips away. An hour spent rehearsing Thursday's meeting is an hour not spent on Tuesday. Seneca does not dismiss the future. His point is that the present is where life is lived, and anxiety about tomorrow can take it from us without our noticing.

The other side

It would be dishonest to present Seneca as having solved worry. In another letter, he tells Lucilius to cut away two things: the fear of future suffering and the memory of past suffering, since the one no longer concerns us and the other does not concern us yet (Seneca, c. 65/1917, Letter 78). Few people can simply cut away a fear, and Seneca, who wrote these letters while under real threat, probably knew it.

What his letters offer is a method. Look at the fear. Ask what kind it is. Bring your attention back to what is in front of you. Do it again tomorrow. That is close to how modern approaches to worry work, and it is a method anyone can practise.

Putting Seneca's questions to work

This exercise turns Letter 13 into a short written practice. It takes about fifteen minutes, and works best at a set time instead of at two in the morning.

  1. Write the worry as a prediction. Turn the feeling into a sentence about what you expect to happen. "Thursday's meeting will go badly and I'll lose credibility" is a prediction you can check later.

  2. Ask Seneca's first question: is it as big as it feels? Rate how bad the outcome would be, from 0 to 10. Then rate it again as if it were happening to a friend.

  3. Ask the second question: is it now? Write the date the feared event would happen. If it is not today, note what, if anything, you can usefully do about it today.

  4. Ask the third question: is it mine? Mark which parts are in your control and which are not. The parts outside your control are where most of the circling happens.

  5. Do the useful thing, if there is one. If the questions turned up a step, such as preparing one answer for the meeting, do it or schedule it.

  6. Check the prediction afterwards. Once the date has passed, go back and write what actually happened. Over a few weeks, you will build your own record of how often worry predicts the future.

Choose, try, adjust

The last step is the one that changes things over time. A single checked prediction proves little. A page of them, most of which did not come true, gives you evidence of your own to set against the next worry. If some predictions do come true, note how you coped. That is evidence too.

Expect worry to return. Seneca wrote about it repeatedly because it kept coming back, to him as much as anyone. The aim is to meet it with better questions each time it does.

Some people find it easier to examine their worries with someone else asking the questions. If that would help, the first conversation with us is free.

If someone you know spends their nights living through tomorrow, feel free to share this with them.

References

LaFreniere, L. S., & Newman, M. G. (2020). Exposing worry's deceit: Percentage of untrue worries in generalized anxiety disorder treatment. Behavior Therapy, 51(3), 413–423. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2019.07.003

Seneca, L. A. (1917). Ad Lucilium epistulae morales (R. M. Gummere, Trans., Vol. 1). William Heinemann. (Original work written c. 65)

Watkins, E. R. (2008). Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought. Psychological Bulletin, 134(2), 163–206. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.134.2.163

Previous
Previous

Why a low mood makes the past feel like proof

Next
Next

How pressure shrinks your options